Buffalo Bills: 6 draft prospects that can replace Isaiah McKenzie

Since his first game for the Buffalo Bills in week 10 of the 2018 season, Isaiah McKenzie has been a swiss-army knife in terms of usage. McKenzie has provided value in multiple ways, on offense with production as a pass catcher and ball carrier, as well as on special teams as a return specialist. His versatility is a big part of how he got on the field in Buffalo.

During his career with the Buffalo Bills, McKenzie has 103 total touches for 839 yards from scrimmage and 8 total touchdowns. About 25% of that total production came in the running game via jet sweeps and reverses. Although McKenzie was hidden behind one of the best returners in the league, Andre Roberts, he still managed to get on the field for some opportunities. However, he is much better as a punt returner specifically, where he racked up 175 yards and returned one for a touchdown on 16 attempts.

Given the circumstances of this offseason, the Bills have to save money anywhere they can. Although McKenzie was basically on a rookie minimum contract, he contributed far greater than his contract value and earned some money for himself. He probably wants to come back to Buffalo and the Bills would probably like to have him back, but only at the right price. I’m assuming they aren’t willing to go over $2M annually.

If McKenzie holds out for a better deal on the free agent market, the Buffalo Bills will likely try to replace him with a cheaper option in free agency or the draft. The Bills certainly value this type of role on the team, but I’m not convinced they are willing to spend a first round pick on this type of player. If the Bills elect to find McKenzie’s replacement in the draft, here are 6 names projected to go after the first round to keep on your radar. All 6 of these prospects have traits and play styles predicated around speed, elusiveness, and agility, similar to McKenzie.