James Cook's dominance continues to silence contract doubters

New Orleans Saints v Buffalo Bills - NFL 2025
New Orleans Saints v Buffalo Bills - NFL 2025 | Lauren Leigh Bacho/GettyImages

Typically when players get their big contracts, the progression starts to slow down. History has shown us that once a player gets paid, they don’t always continue the production that they were putting up before. Whether it’s offense or defense, there are so many examples of it.

For the Buffalo Bills, they are getting a bit of a bargain on what could be to come regarding running back James Cook, who signed a four-year extension worth $48 million. After two strong seasons in Buffalo, Cook was entering his final contractual year in Buffalo. There was a dispute between Cook and the organization, and it was getting a little out of hand.

It was more public than maybe what the front office was hoping for. Nonetheless, both sides agreed to terms and now Cook is signed for five seasons including this current one. So far, through the first four weeks, he is proving why the Bills made the right decision to extend him.

Cook has rushed for 401 yards and 5 touchdowns, averaging 5.3 yards per carry. At times, he has been the best player on offense for the Bills whenever Josh Allen doesn’t have to carry the team to a win. He has also rushed for 100+ yards the last three consecutive games.

James Cook keeps on silencing doubters he had before contract signing

Mason Cameron from Pro Football Focus (PFF) has grades from Week 4 posted (subscription required) and when it comes to James Cook, it proves yet why the Bills made the right decision to pay Cook when they did. Here’s what Cameron said about Cook’s Week 4 performance:

"James Cook has been on fire through the first month of the season. In Sunday’s game against the Saints, he recorded his third straight 100-yard performance, averaging 5.3 yards per carry and forcing six missed tackles. His 86.5 PFF rushing grade led all qualifying running backs through Sunday."
Mason Cameron, PFF

The Bills should be very thankful that they paid Cook when they did. Can you imagine if Cook was putting up these numbers on a contract year, and then the Bills would potentially have to pay Cook a bigger contract than what they did? I’m not saying that the Bills are getting a huge discount, but right now, no one can argue the fact that Cook has been a star for the Bills.

More Bills news and analysis: