Round 2, Pick 41: NT, Torell Troup, Central Florida
Back in 2010 Torell Troup wasn’t the worst idea for a pick, but the disappointing part of Troup’s selection was the fact that a TE from Arizona named Rob Gronkowski was the very next pick selected at 42 by the New England Patriots. Troup was only with Buffalo until 2013 and was signed by the Oakland Raiders as a reserve/future free agent until he was released on August 2014.
Round 3, Pick 72: DE, Alex Carrington, Central Arkansas
Alex Carrington was another player who didn’t spend much time in the NFL, playing with the Bills’ until 2013. After the Bills, Carrington signed with the St. Louis Rams before coming back to Buffalo the following season. Carrington ended his career with the Houston Texans in 2016.