Bears Defeat Bills 10-3 in Preseason Opener

by Game Recaps

Shawne Merriman's Buffalo debut went about as well as it possibly could have.

The Bills and Bears opened up their respective preseason schedules Saturday night, with Chicago defeating Buffalo 10-3. Bears backup QB Caleb Hanie ran for 2-yard score for the game’s only touchdown.

Despite the somewhat ugly scoreline, there certainly some positives for the Bills:

- The first-team offense looked pretty decent. QB Ryan Fitzpatrick was fine (7-for-9, 44 yards) and everyone seemed comfortable. Fred Jackson had a very nice run early.

- TE Scott Chandler had a few early catches, and Fitz commented later that he has very high hopes for Chandler.

- QB Brad Smith was very effective running out of the Wildcat (three runs for first downs)…and I’m sure we’ve only scratched the surface of how Chan Gailey plans to use him.

- The Bills recorded nine (?!) sacks as a team, highlighted by brilliant back-to-back sacks by LB Shawne Merriman. “Lights out” was certainly that tonight. He looked fantastic. OLB Danny Batten, who missed his entire rookie season in 2010 with injury, also had two sacks.

- First-round pick Marcell Dareus was in on a sack and looked pretty good. He’s a very large man.

- Second-round draft pick CB Aaron Williams got beat for a few plays in one drive, but then ended that same drive with a nice interception on a tipped pass.

- The backup defense wasn’t great, but DT Kellen Heard and OLB Robert Eddins had some nice moments. Keep an eye on those two.

- There weren’t any major injuries. Considering the terrible playing surface, that’s a huge victory.

Of course, there were also some negatives:

- The offense was a train wreck once the starters left. Obviously with so little practice time this was going to be hard, but it was ugly.

- Tyler Thigpen (1-for-5, 5 yards) didn’t have a good night. Levi Brown (7-for-15, 53 yards, 1 INT) probably cost himself any chance he had of making this team.

- The second-string offensive line was a disaster. Poor Johnny White (nine carries, 13 yards) had absolutely nowhere to run, and the Bears’ rush was in the faces of Thigpen and Brown all night.

- The backup defenders had a lot of trouble stopping the run. Bears RB Kahlil Bell (13 carries, 73 yards) often had huge running lanes to choose from.

All in all, pretty solid. There’s only so much you can take away from the first preseason game, but this wasn’t a bad start. The first string certainly looked decent, but there’s a terrifying lack of depth on this team at several key positions (offensive line especially).

Comments
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MatC 5 pts

In terms of backup quarterbacks, I really don't know who I'd choose at this point. Sure Levi Brown didn't do very well, but in my opinion Thigpen looked awful. It seemed like he was consistently throwing high, or just missing completely. Maybe he didn't have enough downs to show his ability (or to get an INT, like Brown did) but I don't know that one is truly a better option than the other, judging only from that game. Now, that calculus may well change if you look at prior performance, especially since Brown has never been awesome for the Bills. But looking just at Saturday's game, I think Thigpen looked bad.

Brad Andrews 5 pts

MatC Thigpen definitely looked bad...but he had a bit more of an excuse. For one thing, because of this year's weird rules Thigpen didn't get to practice at all until Aug. 4. I think Thigpen needs to look bad again this week before I worry too much.

Also, if both guys continue to stink, Thigpen's going to have the edge simply because he's had some NFL success in the past.