Advertisement

Bills make surprising free agency signing that fans thought would not happen

Brandon Ray
Brandon Ray

BuffaLowDown

Sep 14, 2025; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin (3) after the game against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Robert Deutsch-Imagn Images / Robert Deutsch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

When the Buffalo Bills decided to go out and bring in two safeties in C.J. Gardner-Johnson and Geno Stone, a lot of fans had thought that the Bills were truly going in a new direction on the backend of the defense. However, the Bills are still keeping well-known ties with a player that has been with the organization that will now get his third contract from the Bills.

The Bills reported that they have agreed to a one-year deal with safety Damar Hamlin. He will now be back in Buffalo to join a room that features Gardner-Johnson, Stone, and Cole Bishop and he will be looking to compete for a roster spot.

Bills sign Damar Hamlin to third contract with organization (and fans are surprised)

The Bills drafted Hamlin in the 6th round of the 2021 NFL Draft, and has had some valuable playing experience in his tenure with the Bills. The 2022 season is where he really got to show Bills Mafia what he could do where he recorded 91 total tackles and even had 1.5 sacks.

Hamlin would then gain valuable playing time in 2024 where he was a full-time starter where he had 89 total tackles and even recorded his first two career interceptions with the Bills. Last offseason, Hamlin was brought back on a one-year deal and he did end up making the final roster going into Week 1.

However, he was limited to just five games due to a pectoral injury he had in the middle of the season.

When Sean McDermott was fired by the Bills in January, it signaled a start of a new look at One Bills Drive, and that included the roster as well. Especially since the Bills had already signed Gardner-Johnson and Stone to contracts, a lot of people thought that Hamlin would not fit in the team’s vision moving forward. Well, the Bills are bringing him back and it might even just be to compete in camp.

At the same time, Hamlin keeps a little continuity on defense but he should not be a starter for the Bills in 2026 if he does indeed make the roster. The Bills need aggressive playmakers and while Hamlin has shown some plays that raised some eyebrows, he hasn’t been dynamic. With the scheme that Jim Leonhard wants to run, it will be interesting to see how Hamlin fits into it.

Brandon Ray

Brandon Ray

Brandon Ray is a contributor for FanSided, with main coverage for the Buffalo Bills and Tennessee Titans. Brandon joined FanSided in 2023 and has had the chance to cover multiple teams over his tenure. His work has been featured on different media outlets including Sports Illustrated and Bleacher Report. When Brandon isn't writing about the Bills and Titans, he is planning his next NFL stadium visit trip with his wife. As of the 2025 season, Brandon has been to 8 stadiums.