Soon to be former 49ers QB, Alex Smith, is on his way to Kansas City

San Francisco not the place to look for Bills QB

March 12th is a big day.  For me, it will mark the first day of my 30′s.  For the Kansas City Chiefs, it will make the acquisition of former San Francisco 49ers QB Alex Smith.  Recently, former Bills Hall of Fame quarterback, Jim Kelly, stated on a nationally syndicated radio program that he felt Smith was the right QB for the Bills.  Apparently Kansas City was either quick to the trigger, or their 2nd round and conditional draft picks were more compelling for the NFC Champions.

As I previously stated, I have yet to believe that Alex smith is a good NFL QB.  Was I being tricked when he nearly lost his job to J.T. O’Sullivan, or when he guided his team to the 2012 NFC Championship game?  Smith may have been a realistic option for the Bills, but I don’t think he was the right one.  On a regular basis I read a blog from a certain sports network blogger, who has little to few kind words about Ryan Fitzpatrick.  Yes he can be inconsistent, and yes he can make some bad decisions.  Yet, from a  statistical stand point he’s improved each each year.  His interception total in 2012 was down by 7 from the previous year.  He’s thrown for 3,ooo plus yards the last 3 seasons.  His number one wide receiver was a 7th round draft pick.

I’m not saying that Fitz is the person for the job, but that his criticism is unfair.  There’s not another NFL quarterback that I think would be a realistic and winning scenario for the Bills.  Yes, Seattle’s Matt Flynn has been mentioned.  However, wasn’t it a one game performance that had the experts drooling?  There was another guy that did that.  His name was Scott Michell.  Having grown up in metro Detroit, I can take several days to rattle off the nasty things Lions fans had to say about him.  I could be wrong, but after the money Buffalo through at Fitz, I’m unwilling for the Bills to take any chances.

With Smith off the trading block, I think the the draft is the directions the Bills need to turn.  If we learned anything form this year’s combine, it’s what we predicted.  A weak QB class.  Not surprising since last’s year class produced three quarterbacks  that led their team to the playoffs.  Former West Virginia quarterback, Gino Smith, continues to be the front runner of draft experts.  If he’s available, I think the Bills need to go get him.  He can be mobile, he’s accurate, and most importantly:  He makes good decisions.  I know it’s been inferred that new head coach, Doug Marone, is in love with his former Syracuse stud, Ryan Nassib, but I’m hesitant for the Bills to draft a QB who’s been labeled to have a “weak arm.”  From what I’ve read, I think they already have a Harvard grad with that label.

So, let’s recap:  Smith is going to KC, frequently mentioned Matt Flynn could be the next “Scott Mitchell,” and Gino smith is like a shiny gem among a bunch of fools gold.  I’m grateful Alex Smith won’t be one of my 30th birthday presents.  So, how about we sign some free agents at wide receiver (cough cough Dwayne Bowe), linebacker, and pray to the lord above that Gino falls to us in the draft.  Wishful thinking?  Maybe?  Or is it just a premature middle age crisis?


Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

  • NWBill

    I agree with you about Fitz, and Geno Smith for the Bills. Ideally, we’ll see Fitz step it up more in Marrone’s West Coast offense, and the Bills also draft Smith (or Nassib) to learn for a year or two – and be there in case we’re wrong about Fitz. You bring up a very good point that I think way too many people forget about Fitz; he has been playing with essentially ONE quality WR for the past three years. All the other guys have either (a) been injured, (b) not good fits for the offense, or (c) rookies who were unproven. If I were an NFL defensive coordinator, I’d spend the least amount of time prepping for the Bills, even with CJ Spiller and Fred Jackson. Why? Because they have been perennially hamstrung with their WRs. You have ONE guy to cover, and tell everyone else to focus on Chandler and the RBs. What’s difficult about that? Having seen the Bills dump WRs recently, I get the feeling Marrone & Co. have figured that out, too, and will be stocking up on quality WRs anywhere they can get them. If they get Smith or Nassib, great. Whatever. What this team REALLY needs are quality WRs and playmaking linebackers. From what I’ve seen since Marrone was hired, the Bills brain trust agrees with me.

  • John

    Those stats on Fitz may be correct but when it comes down to winning a game he blows it.

  • NWBill

    Time will tell if you’re right, or not. I would say that 2013 is a make-or-break year for him in Buffalo … unless something happens between now and the start of the season. Ideally, he’s a good match with Marrone and Hackett; if not, then it’s goodbye. They’re paying him too much for it to be anything else.